|
Written by Irish VRT.ie
|
|
Saturday, 19 April 2008 10:49 |
|
In considering moving to a more CO2 emissions related VRT system, either partly or fully, there are a number of issues that have to be taken into account, including reasons for making such a move on a phased basis over a period of years.
- Too rapid a move would adversely affect especially the second hand car market.
- Given the yield from VRT it would be very unwise to put such a level of revenue at risk, even if the risk is rather limited, all at the one time.
- Cars result in costs and have adverse effects on society beyond those arising from CO2 emissions and consequently there is a strong case to be made for not having VRT, and indeed motor tax, even in the long term, set solely in relation to CO2 emissions.
- Unless it is planned to abolish VRT, or reduce significantly the yield from VRT, the changes made should be broadly revenue neutral, at least in the short term.
- Success in reducing CO2 emissions will reduce revenue over time.
- Any new or revised VRT system must by able to be applied to second hand imports as well as to new cars.
- Any short term, or immediate, changes being made should be such that they do not prevent further progress being made or predetermine the longer-term structure and for the VRT system.
- The changes should be such that they facilitate, if so desired, the ongoing progress towards making VRT ever more CO2 emissions related.
- Any more CO2 emissions related VRT system should take account of the Emissions Labelling system the Department of Environment, Heritage and Local Government are considering rather than adopting a different approach.
- VRT is effectively a self-assessment tax and the VRT system should be as easy as possible to understand, apply and administer.
- Any new VRT system should be internally balanced and consistent as a tax.
- Introducing an partly or fully CO2 emissions related system across all new and second hard cars would take 6 to 8 months to technically implement. (Changes in existing rates and bands or adding an extra band could be technically implemented at fairly short notice.)
- SIMI have also stressed that, as their members, order cars well in advance, they would need reasonable advanced notice of any significant changes being made.
Taken from the Tax Strategy Group Papers - Budget 2007
 |